Brandon proposed to Cavesha on a cold night under the stars in Theodore, Alabama. They were amongst the many Christmas lights and surrounded by the calm of the evening. Cavesha tried to talk Brandon out of taking her when she found out how low the temperature would drop (20s). However, he was persistant and promised she would not regret it. Even though their fingers and toes were practically frozen, nothing could stop the warmth felt from the heart. Brandon was said to have stopped others who were walking by and in the tour group to ask them to take pictures, that's when Cavesha began to catch the hint. Although she did not know "exactly" when it would happen. Brandon was so happy (who else would smile the whole time as cold as it was in "church shoes")? Cavesha said "Yes".